Sample essay on do ends justify the means

Monday, 11 May 2015.

International human rights, to ensure the inviolability of the person, are not subject to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (CID). These are different ways of hurting people to get specific information. The experts, however, argue that these methods have a reasonable difference. In Nowak and MacArthur (2006), there is a line between torture and degrading treatment. Thus, it is possible to distinguish between these terms, which have been well known to the degree of suffering

Under United Nations conventions against torture, the denial of food and drink is not tantamount to torture unless it is accompanied by long-term psychological damage (Bakalar, 2007). However, the difference between torture and CID depends on the nature, purpose and intensity of the treatment used. Not all inhumane acts constitute torture. For example, a loud noise from the environment cannot be comparable to a terrorist who takes away the victim’s tongue. Clearly, the degree of pain in both cases is different. The Naveki and MacArthur had nothing to do with degrading treatment without serious pain, while torture inflicted physical and mental pain (2006)

Ophtentis, investigators can use excessive force and tactics to get information from dangerous terrorists.

While the perpetrators deserved to be subjected to forced interrogation, they should not be extradited to countries known to use torture when interroturing suspects.  In some cases, the perpetrators obtain excessive fines to force them to confess. This amounts to human rights abuses and integrity. For example, some countries in the Middle East have mutilated the body of the victim as a method of interrogation. Guantánamo is an example of a prison known to torture victims even if they are willing to provide information voluntarily (Carey, 2012). Countries that do not have the capacity to conduct a survey to interview deadly criminals may be ahead of them. Suspects in terrorism must therefore be questioned in the countries that they are targeted and are not in another state (Cary, 2012)

The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) prohibits torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment (Langley, 2010).  Clarke argues that no country can make exceptions after ratification of the treaty (2012).  While some countries use rendition to transfer criminals to other states, irregular reproductions are not permitted. Rendition is acceptable when the country is unable to question specific criminals and provides them in well-informed countries. Nerunary rendition is a place in which the offender is secretly transferred to another country, as is known to have weak human rights laws (Langley, 2010).  Clarke describes an irregular rendition as an out-of-court way of presenting criminals, as they are subjected to unnecessary physical and psychological pain (2012). It thus undermines the Bill of Rights and Public Morality

It is not possible to distinguish between torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment (Noark & MacArthur, 2006). Understanding these terms depends on the degree of pain and suffering, the seriousness of the procedure and the nature of the situation. For example, it would be inhuman to accept a suspect who commits crimes at Guantánamo Bay. However, society is comfortable with fatal terrorists being sent to the same prison. Similarly, while less ill-treatment does not amount to torture, they may be cruel. Thus, the authorities should use excessive force and reproduction during interrogation as a last resort. Thus, the use of physical or mental force at a criminal level for humiliation amounts to degrading treatment, while torture applies to severe pain (Carey, 2012)

Get a quick help from the best writing company

Bakalar, N. (2007). The line between torture and cruelty.

Cary, N. F. (2012).

Clark, A. W. (2012).

Langley, E. E. (2010). The loss of American values in the event of errand irregular renditions

Novak, M. and MacArthur, E. (2006). Distination between torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. 16 (3), 147-151

What you can read next